Mortgage interest rates, LIBOR and game theory
This morning’s headline on BBC Breakfast was the news that yesterday RBS raised the interest rate on three of its mortgage products by a quarter of a percent to 4%. Three days ago the Halifax wrote to its mortgage holders saying that it intends to raise the cap on its Standard Variable Rate (SVR) to 3.75% above base rate, rather than the current 3%. As the Telegraph reports, although this doesn’t guarantee that Halifax would raise the rate itself, brokers”… believe otherwise and suggested that this would soon happen for a million Halifax borrowers” – and the BBC are now reporting an expectation that the Halifax will announce a rise in the SVR with effect from 1st May. For A level economists this story has several implications.
The first is clearly in macroeconomics, with the likely effect on consumer spending. We know well how squeezed consumers are, with rises in fuel and food prices, and the Bank of England has regularly expressed the importance of keeping base rates low in order to allow households to keep their heads above water. For mortgage holders with an interest-only mortgage, the RBS rate increase represents a 14% increase in their monthly mortgage payment – highlighted in this BBC video report.
The second concerns kinked demand curves and game theory. We have already seen RBS actually raising their rate and a likelihood that Halifax are about to do the same. Stuart Gregory from Lentune Mortgage Consultancy, who used to work for Halifax, told the Telegraph he expected to see a “chain of events” whereby other lenders also increased rates. “Once one does it, the others see it as an opportunity,” he said. This sounds like oligopoly behaviour to me. Mortgage lenders have all held their rates low for almost three years since Base Rate sunk to 0.5% in March 2009. This could be because, in close competition with each other, they have been stuck on the apex of a kinked demand curve, not feeling that the market would allow them either to raise rates and increase their returns – perhaps because competitors would not follow suit, and in any case their clients couldn’t afford the repayments - or to lower rates and try to gain larger market share – perhaps because they can’t afford the lower margins.
But something must have changed to cause RBS and Halifax to risk moving away from the established position, and guess that others will follow suit. There is certainly no signal from the Monetary Policy Committee or the Bank of England, who are more inclined at the moment to give the impression that 0.5% remains set in stone. The justification given by RBS is a rise in their borrowing costs. Partly due to rises in the LIBOR rate – as this graph shows, there may be some justification for this as there was a significant rise between November 2011 and the end of January 2012, although it has fallen back a little during February.
A second reason may be that savers are becoming more savvy in moving their funds between banks and accounts in order to seek the best possible rate, squeezing the margin between the rate that banks pay to savers and charge to borrowers – a new paradox of thrift. And a third was suggested by Paul Lewis on the BBC this morning; could it be that base rate, stuck so low for so long, is losing its power as a signal to other banks, who see official monetary policy as increasingly disconnected from the real world?
Our popular Economics Teacher National Conference takes place on Monday 22 June 2015 at the superb Wellcome Collection Auditorium on Euston Road in Central London. This is the leading enrichment CPD event for Economics teachers in the UK and always attracts a good number of teaching colleagues from further afield too!Confirmed speaker line-up:Duncan Weldon - BBC Newsnight Economics Correspondent (Economic Policy after the Election)Sir Paul Collier, Oxford University - Where next for Development Economics?Adrian Woolridge (The Economist) - The Great DisruptionDavid Smith (Economics Editor of the Sunday Times) Prospects for the UK EconomyOur delegate prices are:Single Delegate - £175 per personDepartment Deal - £125 per person (for two or more colleagues attending from the same school or college)PGCE / NQT - £75 per person